Searching for humble restaurants in Florida with legendary key lime pies? These 9 modest eateries serve up incredible slices in charming, unpretentious settings! 1. Kermit’s Key ...

Tucked away in the charming coastal town of Nokomis, Captain Eddie’s seafood restaurant serves up slices of key lime pie so divine, you might suspect they’ve hired mermaids as pastry chefs.

Sporting a meringue topping that reaches for the sky, Blue Heaven’s legendary key lime pie has achieved cult status. Located ...