Ryan Seacrest is only on his first season as the new host of Wheel of Fortune, but he is already skating on thin ice with some fans of the game show. Seacrest, 49, is taking some heat after an incident that occurred during the Tuesday,

Wheel of Fortune’s most prized tradition is the bonus round, where each episode’s winner is faced with one last puzzle and a mere 10 seconds to come away with an even bigger bundle of cash (or not). But fans want a word with host Ryan Seacrest about how he’s presenting the prizes after giving a puzzling amount of build-up to a player’s $40,000 win.

Woolery was the original host for Wheel of Fortune, holding the position from 1975 until a salary dispute in 1981. He wanted a raise from the $65,000 per year he was reportedly receiving to $500,000 per year, which the late star said was more comparable to what other hosts — like Richard Dawson and Bob Barker — were making at the time.