Lady Gaga delivered a performance that was fitting for Saturday Night Live’s “Homecoming Concert,” a special musical event in celebration of the show’s 50th anniversary. While some audience members at Radio City Music Hall in New York might have expected the star to sing one of her recently released singles,

The 14x Grammy winner joined Andy Samberg onstage Friday at Radio City Music Hall for SNL50: The Homecoming Concert, where they began performing her A Star Is Born track ‘Shallow’ before deciding to do a selection more in Samberg’s “vocal range.”

Lady Gaga opened with a cover of ‘Dick in a Box’ alongside Andy Samberg before the launch of a Lonely Island medley at the‘SNL 50’ concert.